10 Alternatives to Payday Loans
- Curry Forest

- Jun 28, 2020
- 14 min read
Updated: Nov 5
There are several infinitely better options than payday loans. In fact, absolutely anything is better than high-interest loans.

This article is part of the Personal Debt Series, where we offer practical strategies to pay off debt, achieve financial freedom, and find the emotional support you need along the way.
If you’re struggling to make ends meet, know this - you are not alone.
Over 80% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck, and many of them earn decent incomes. In fact, 1 in 10 people earning over $100,000 and 4 in 10 people earning over $50,000 still live paycheck to paycheck. More than half are in debt, and many can't stretch their paycheck to the end of the month. Unexpected expenses like a medical emergency, a car breakdown, or a home repair can push anyone into a debt spiral.
Unfortunately, predatory lenders exploit this desperation through payday loans, title loans, pawning, rent-to-own schemes, and similar high-interest traps. But you have better options, safer, more sustainable ones.
Here are 10 better alternatives to predatory loans, categorized to help you meet immediate needs, lower fixed expenses, and manage emergencies.
Key:
🟢 = Addresses Immediate Bills (food, utilities)
🟠 = Addresses Lowering Fixed Costs (rent, mortgage, loans)
🔴 = Addresses Variable Costs (medical emergencies, repairs)
Click the '>' symbol to expand and view details related to each section.
Almost every recurring bill can be negotiated or reduced. It takes time, but the savings are worth it. Negotiating bills can free up money for immediate needs 🟢 and lower your overall fixed expenses. 🟠
1. Essential Services & Insurance (Quick Wins 🟢)
1.1) Cable, Internet and Phone:
Research Competitors: Find lower prices or better bundles offered by rivals and ask your current provider to match them.
Switch or Bundle: Consider changing providers or bundling multiple services (internet, phone, TV) for a discount.
Downgrade: Review your usage and downgrade to cheaper plans that meet your actual needs (eg: lower internet speed).
Explore Low-Cost Carriers: For your phone plan, investigate Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs). These carriers use the same major networks but operate with lower overhead, offering significantly cheaper, no-contract plans for individuals or families. Look for options that let you pay for service in bulk (e.g., three or twelve months upfront) for the biggest savings.
1.2) Home Utilities (Water, Power, Gas, Waste etc.):
Budget Plans: Ask your company about fixed-payment plans based on average yearly usage. This prevents bill shock during peak months (hottest/coldest).
Assistance: Inquire about low-income assistance, free energy conservation services, or shareholder-funded support programs.
Government and Nonprofit Resources: Reach out to local nonprofits or government programs for direct utility assistance.
1.3) Car and Home insurance:
Shop Around & Negotiate: Get competitor quotes and use them as leverage to negotiate with your current insurer.
Bundle & Deductibles: Ask about bundling discounts for multiple policies (e.g., home and auto). Choose only state-required liability coverage and consider increasing your deductible to lower premiums.
Explore State-Specific Programs (Auto): Check if your state offers a low-cost automobile insurance program (like those in California, New Jersey, or Hawaii) designed for low-income drivers who meet certain income and driving record requirements.
Check for HAF (Homeowners): If you are a homeowner who experienced financial hardship (often related to COVID-19), check for the Homeowner Assistance Fund (HAF) in your state. HAF funds can sometimes be used to assist with past-due homeowner's insurance payments and other housing-related costs.
Utilize Insurance Discounts: Don't miss out on common discounts like good student discounts, driver safety course completion, good driver records, or telematics/usage-based programs that monitor driving habits to reduce rates.
2. Loans & Major Debts (High-Impact Savings 🟠)
If you are facing financial difficulty or seeking major savings, you have options beyond simple rate shopping.
2.1) For credit card interest rates:
If you have high credit card debt, fixing the interest rate is critical:
Call and Request: Contact your provider and request a lower Annual Percentage Rate (APR), especially if you have a strong payment history or your credit utilization is low (balance below 30% of the limit).
Consolidation/Transfer: Consider a 0% balance transfer card (if you can pay it off before the introductory period ends) or a nonprofit debt management program (DMP) via groups like the NFCC or FCAA.
Debt Consolidation Loan: Look into a debt consolidation loan through a bank or credit union. Warning: Only proceed if the new loan rate is fixed, low, and clear for the full term, and you are committed to changing spending habits.
2.2) Home Mortgage & Car Loans
If you are facing financial difficulty or seeking major savings, you have options beyond simple rate shopping.
Work with Experts & Negotiate:
Consult a HUD-Certified Housing Counselor: For mortgage difficulties, this is your first and often free line of defense. These counselors provide independent advice, can walk you through complex loan options, and help you find local government programs.
Check for State Assistance: Explore government programs like the Homeowner Assistance Fund (HAF) in your state, which provides funds to cover missed mortgage payments, homeowner's insurance, and property taxes for those who qualify.
Car Loan Hardship: For car loans, ask your lender about their Hardship Programs. If you are overwhelmed, consult with a nonprofit credit counselor (like those affiliated with NFCC) who can help assess your overall budget and advise on your best course of action.
Leverage Home Equity
Reappraisal for PMI Removal: If your home's value has increased significantly since you bought it, ordering a new appraisal can prove your Loan-to-Value (LTV) ratio is below 80%. This allows you to request the removal of Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI), saving you money instantly without refinancing.
Refinancing for Better Terms: If interest rates have dropped, refinancing can lower your monthly payment, reduce total interest paid, or help you switch from a variable to a more stable fixed rate. Even a slight rate drop can save thousands over time.
Working with Lenders During Hardship
If you are struggling to make payments, contact your loan servicer immediately to discuss alternatives to default:
Loan Modification: This is a permanent restructuring of your loan (eg: lower interest rate, extended loan term) to make monthly payments more affordable for the long term.
Forbearance: This allows you to temporarily pause or reduce your payments (typically 3–12 months) during a short-term financial crisis (e.g., job loss, medical emergency). Be sure to understand how the missed payments will be repaid (often deferral to the end of the loan).
Repayment Plan: If you've missed a few payments but are now stable, the lender may allow you to repay the missed amount over a short, defined period by slightly increasing your monthly payment.
State-Specific Funds: Check for state programs like the Homeowner Assistance Fund (HAF), which provides funds to cover missed mortgage payments, homeowner's insurance, and property taxes for those who experienced pandemic-related financial hardship.
Housing Counselors: Contact a HUD-certified housing counselor. They provide free, confidential advice and can walk you through your specific loan options (like FHA, VA, or USDA) and local government programs.
Car Loan Assistance: If you have a car loan, ask your lender about their Hardship Programs (similar to those offered by credit card companies) which may include temporary payment deferral or a reduction in interest.
2.3) Student Debt
Seek Out a Nonprofit Counselor: Start with nonprofit student loan counselors (many of whom are affiliated with organizations like NFCC or TISLA). They offer free, unbiased advice, can clarify complicated federal rules, and help you choose the best repayment path (like Income-Driven Repayment plans).
Talk to a Dedicated Student Loan Advisor: For complex private or mixed loans, consider consulting an advisor who specializes only in student debt. They can guide you through advanced strategies like refinancing and forgiveness programs.
Repayment and Forgiveness Options
Explore Assistance Programs: Immediately look into loan forgiveness and repayment assistance programs, especially if you work in public service (PSLF) or high-need fields (like teaching or medicine).
Call Your Lender (Servicer): Start by calling the loan servicer. Simply asking can sometimes lower your private loan rate, and you can use competitive offers as leverage.
Refinancing: Refinancing private or mixed loans can simplify payments and reduce interest. Warning: Refinancing federal loans into a private loan means giving up access to federal protections like Income-Driven Repayment plans and forgiveness programs.
Perks: Even setting up autopay may drop your rate by 0.25%.
3. Housing & Medical Bills (Sensitive Negotiations 🔴)
3.1) For house rent: If you are a reliable renter, landlords prefer stability:
Find Emergency Help First: If you are facing an imminent crisis, immediately call 2-1-1 or search for your local Emergency Rental Assistance Program (ERAP). This can connect you to city, county, and state funds.
Seek Nonprofit Aid: Reach out to major national and local nonprofits like Catholic Charities or The Salvation Army who often provide one-time emergency rent and utility payments for qualifying individuals.
Ask About Subsidies: Ask about rent assistance programs for which the landlord may be able to apply on your behalf. Many state and local programs allow or even require the landlord to initiate the application to secure payment.
Show Your Value: Remind your landlord that finding a new renter is costly (vacancy, cleaning, listing).
Propose Alternatives: Offer to sign a long-term lease or take on minor maintenance tasks in exchange for a lower rent increase (or even a small reduction).
Market Data: If your rent is above local averages, show the landlord comparisons.
Be Empathetic: Many landlords depend on rent for their livelihood. Seek a win-win solution.
3.2) For Medical Bills:
Never wait until a bill goes to collections. Negotiate early!
Immediate Financial Assistance
Hospital Financial Aid (Charity Care): Ask the hospital billing department for their Financial Hardship Program or Charity Care policy. Many hospitals are required by law to provide free or discounted services based on income, even if you have some insurance.
Government/Local Help: Immediately call 2-1-1 or contact your local Department of Social Services to inquire about Medicaid eligibility or other emergency government assistance programs that may cover past-due medical costs.
Targeted Nonprofit and Prescription Help
Nonprofit Grants: Seek out national disease-specific nonprofits (like the Patient Access Network Foundation or HealthWell Foundation) that provide grants to help cover co-pays, deductibles, and premiums for patients with chronic or life-threatening illnesses.
Prescription Assistance Programs (PAPs): Investigate Patient Assistance Programs run by pharmaceutical companies, which often provide expensive, brand-name medications for free or at a low cost to uninsured or underinsured patients. Use resources like NeedyMeds or RxAssist to find these.
Negotiation and Advocacy
Upfront Payment Discount: Hospitals may offer a significant discount if you offer to pay the total balance in full on the same day.
Advocates: Consider hiring a Medical Billing Advocate to review the bill for overcharges and errors and negotiate the price down on your behalf.
Payment Plans: Explore setting up an interest-free payment plan directly with the hospital. Warning: Avoid medical credit cards unless you are 100% sure you can repay the balance before the 0% interest window closes.
Also Read:
2. Renegotiate your current debt repayments. 🟠
If your current debt feels overwhelming, take proactive steps to renegotiate and find a path to financial freedom.
Step 1: Get Expert Guidance
Start by getting advice from a professional who is legally bound to act in your best interest:
Consult a Fee-Only Fiduciary Financial Advisor: They can assess your overall financial picture and recommend the best strategy, whether it's negotiation, consolidation, or exploring specific relief programs.
Speak with a Debt Relief Lawyer: If your situation is complex or you're considering bankruptcy, a lawyer can provide legal options and protect your rights.
Step 2: Proactively Contact Your Creditors
Contact your creditors as soon as you realize you'll have trouble making payments. Be proactive and honest about your financial hardship. Many creditors prefer to work with you than risk a full default, so it's a critical step.
Ask for Their Hardship Program: Explain your specific situation (eg: job loss, medical expenses) and ask the representative to walk you through their Financial Hardship Program or Payment Assistance Options.
Request Options: Ask for specific forms of relief available under their program, such as lower interest rates, deferred payments (forbearance), or a new, more manageable payment plan. Be prepared to provide documentation (like a termination letter or medical bill) to qualify.
Step 3: Seek Help for Credit Card Debt
If you're dealing with huge credit card balances, a specialized credit counseling agency can be extremely effective.
Work with an Accredited Nonprofit: Organizations like the NFCC (National Foundation for Credit Counseling) or FCAA (Financial Counseling Association of America) can help you create a formal Debt Management Plan (DMP).
The Benefits of a DMP: These plans often allow you to consolidate your unsecured debts (like credit cards) into one monthly payment, frequently resulting in significantly reduced interest rates and helping you pay off the principal faster while you restore your credit.
Step 4: Escalate When Negotiation Fails
If you've tried to resolve a dispute directly with your creditor and received an unsatisfactory answer, you have recourse:
Contact a Regulator: File a formal complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) for issues with banks, lenders, and credit reporting agencies.
Utilize an Ombudsman: If the dispute is with a specific institution (like a bank or insurance company), you can contact the appropriate Ombudsman. This independent official investigates unresolved complaints and acts as a neutral dispute resolver.
Also Read:
15 Places to Save on Bills: Just by Calling Customer Service
3. Find a low-interest personal loan in other places. 🟠 🔴
If you have decent credit, a personal loan from a credit union or bank is far better than payday loans.
Compare APRs, terms, and fees.
Choose fixed interest rates and no-prepayment-penalty options.
Avoid loans with vague terms, balloon payments, or variable rates unless you fully understand the risks.
Warning: You need to be careful when you get this loan. Not all credit unions offer official PALs. The ones that don't offer official PALs might have low interest rates, but high application fees and other fees that drive up the cost of the loan. You need to find one that is regulated by the National Credit Union Administration. There are also several private banks (and payday lenders!) who fool people into thinking they are getting a "payday alternative loan". Do you research, read the fine print, and don't get it if the interest rates and fees are outlandish. As a rule, don't borrow from any lending institution who won't check your credit score! There's no bigger red flag that that! (I want to add a note about borrowing from or withdrawing from your 401K. I wouldn't recommend this unless you are in an absolute dire strait. But sometimes, it might be your only option if you are unable to find a low-interest loan with a bank! Talk to a financial advisor about it).
4. Consider setting up a donation pay on a crowdfunding platform. 🔴
For urgent, unexpected expenses (like a medical crisis), crowdfunding can provide community-based support.
Share your story with honesty and humility.
Ask friends and community groups to help spread the word.
5. Find a side-hustle: 🟢 🟠
Boosting your income, even temporarily, can make a major difference.
Offer tutoring, babysitting, pet care, or food delivery.
Sell handmade crafts, baked goods, or used items online.
Ask the local stores in your area if they have any open positions.
Take up gig work like freelancing or virtual assistance on micro work sites.
Schools and colleges are always looking for substitute teachers.
Join a ride-hailing service, apply for a first-responder job, deliver packages.
Make money filling out surveys, writing product reviews, joining focus groups.
Many of these can be done with flexible hours and no upfront investment.
You can visit your local employment agencies and ask them if they have any temporary jobs that need your skill.
6. Talk to nonprofits. 🟢 🔴
Local nonprofits and religious institutions often offer assistance for:
Food and groceries
Utility bills
School supplies and bills
Rent and medical needs
If a nonprofit does not offer a service that works for you, they will point you to one. So don't hesitate to ask them for help! Also look up your city's emergency relief programs. Dial 211 to connect with social services in your area. Many offer one-time emergency funds or ongoing support.
I share a full directory of government and nonprofit support programs and services.
7. Rent a room in your house. 🟠
If your home has extra space:
Rent out a room short-term or long-term.
Consider renting to a trusted student, senior, or remote worker.
Ensure clear expectations and a formal agreement.
Renting a room is a fairly straightforward process, but each State and County has its own laws. Be sure to comply with all the requirements. Write up a short lease agreement so the renter understands their obligations. Renting a room will save you a few hundred dollars (or more, depending on where you live) a month! This is a powerful way to offset mortgage or rent costs.
8. Sell your personal items. 🟢
Instead of pawning valuable items (which offers very little cash and high interest), sell them directly through online marketplaces or garage sales.
Items like electronics, jewelry, clothing, tools, and musical instruments can bring in quick cash.
Consider selling your car and buying a cheaper used vehicle if your current one is under a loan.
Avoid pawnshops... they offer less than 50% of resale value and charge exorbitant rates (up to 300% APR in some states). You will also be charged other fees, such as insurance and storage costs!
9. Borrow from a loved one, and do it the right way, with the right attitude. 🟢
A short-term loan from a trusted friend or family member is often the safest and least expensive solution for small bills like groceries or utilities.
Be honest and specific about your situation and how you'll use the money.
Draft a written agreement (a promissory note) with clear repayment terms.
Maintain trust by repaying on time and staying accountable.
Even if they can’t help financially, emotional support or help with childcare, carpooling, or shared meals can save you money.
Important Note: Avoid asking loved ones to co-sign a loan unless absolutely necessary. Co-signing a loan is a serious commitment. While it can help you secure a lower interest rate or get approved when your credit isn’t strong enough, it also puts your loved one at significant financial risk. If you fail to make payments, the co-signer becomes legally responsible for repaying the loan, sometimes the full amount. This can damage their credit score, affect their debt-to-income ratio, and even limit their ability to qualify for future credit or housing. In some cases, there may also be tax implications. So think of co-signing as asking someone to take out a loan themselves. It’s a huge ask, and not one to be made lightly. If you must go this route, be completely transparent. Treat it with the same seriousness and professionalism as you would when applying to a bank—because to them, it’s exactly that.
10. Get an advance from your employer. 🟢 🔴
Many employers offer salary advances, especially if you’ve been a loyal and reliable employee.
This is a loan against your future wages, usually with structured repayment.
Some companies deduct the full amount from your next paycheck, others spread it out.
There may be fees or repayment clauses in case of termination. Ask for details.
If your employer doesn’t have a formal program, propose a plan and offer to take on extra work. You might be surprised how willing they are to help. Offer to work more hours or pick up extra shifts. If you are earnest, your employer will help you.
Conclusion:
High-interest payday and predatory loans may seem like quick solutions, but they often lead to deeper financial trouble. Instead, take control by: Using available resources (family, employers, nonprofits). Re-evaluating your bills and expenses. Increasing your income through smart, short-term strategies.
These steps won’t just help you meet immediate needs, they’ll help you regain long-term financial control. You’ve got more options than you think. And you don’t have to do this alone.
Read more about:
Why Payday Loan Is a Trap: Payday Loans trap people in a debt-cycle by exploiting legal loopholes, following exploitative practices, and deceiving people.
Ten tips to make your food budget stretch till the end of the month: Shopping tips to get the most bang for your buck. It shares where and when to buy your food and what to avoid.
From Snowballs to Avalanches: Finding the Right Debt Repayment Strategy: Common strategies and help you find the right debt repayment method for your situation.
Resources:
MIT Living Wage Calculator: This tool estimates the minimum income required to meet basic living expenses in specific regions, promoting awareness of labor practices and sustainable economic systems.
Visit our Resources page for a full directory of government and nonprofit support programs and services.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or professional advice. The information provided, including budgeting strategies, alternatives to high-interest loans, and program descriptions, is general in nature and may not apply to your specific financial situation, family circumstances, or local regulations. Eligibility for government and community programs, as well as the terms of financial products, can vary significantly and are subject to change.
We strongly recommend consulting with a qualified financial advisor, credit counselor, legal professional, or other relevant expert to discuss your individual circumstances and explore the best options for your debt management. Always research and verify information from official sources before making any financial decisions. If you identify any inaccuracies or outdated information, please contact us with the correct details and official sources. Your feedback helps us improve and maintain the quality of our content.











Comments