10 Alternatives to Payday Loans
- Curry Forest
- Jun 28, 2020
- 10 min read
Updated: 6 days ago
There are several infinitely better options than payday loans. In fact, absolutely anything is better than high-interest loans.
This article is part of the Personal Debt Series, where we offer practical strategies to pay off debt, achieve financial freedom, and find the emotional support you need along the way.
If you’re struggling to make ends meet, know this - you are not alone.
Over 80% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck, and many of them earn decent incomes. In fact, 1 in 10 people earning over $100,000 and 4 in 10 people earning over $50,000 still live paycheck to paycheck. More than half are in debt, and many can't stretch their paycheck to the end of the month. Unexpected expenses like a medical emergency, a car breakdown, or a home repair can push anyone into a debt spiral.
Unfortunately, predatory lenders exploit this desperation through payday loans, title loans, pawning, rent-to-own schemes, and similar high-interest traps. But you have better options, safer, more sustainable ones.
Here are 10 better alternatives to predatory loans, categorized to help you meet immediate needs, lower fixed expenses, and manage emergencies.
Key:
🟢 = Addresses Immediate Bills (food, utilities)
🟠 = Addresses Lowering Fixed Costs (rent, mortgage, loans)
🔴 = Addresses Variable Costs (medical emergencies, repairs)
Almost every recurring bill can be negotiated or reduced. It takes time, but the savings are worth it. Negotiating bills can free up money for immediate needs 🟢 and lower your overall fixed expenses 🟠.
a) For cable, internet and phone bills: 🟢
Research competitor prices and ask your provider to match them.
Consider bundling services or switching providers.
Downgrade to cheaper plans if needed.
b) For house rent: 🟠 If you've been a good renter, you may be able to renegotiate your rent with your landlord. Landlords always prefer known, reliable renters to new renters. Also, your move will cost them money. They will have to get the place back to move-in condition, and will also lose money in the weeks that the house is vacant.
Long-time, reliable renters can negotiate lower rent or propose alternate arrangements like:
Sharing utility costs
Signing a long-term lease
Offering maintenance help
If rent is above local averages, show comparisons to your landlord.
Ask about rent assistance programs your landlord may qualify for on your behalf.
A lot of landlords depend on rent for their livelihood. So be empathetic towards their plight as well, and see what works best for both of you.
c) For home utilities (water, power, gas, waste etc.): 🟢
Many utility companies offer fixed-payment plans based on average yearly usage. This is useful especially in the hottest and coldest months, when energy bills can skyrocket.
Ask about low-income assistance, free energy conservation services, or shareholder-funded support.
Reach out to nonprofits or government programs for utility assistance. You can directly get in touch with them, or reach them through your utility company. Utility companies may have other shareholder or community funded programs as well.
d) For car and home insurance: 🟠
Just as with cable, internet and phone bills, shop around! Use competitor quotes to negotiate with your insurer.
Choose only state-required liability coverage and consider increasing your deductible to lower premiums.
Ask about bundling discounts for multiple policies.
If you have a high credit card interest rate, you need to fix it right away.
Call your provider and request a lower APR, especially if you have a strong payment history or low credit utilization (that is your balance is 30% lower than the limit).
Consider a 0% balance transfer card or a nonprofit debt management program.
Look into debt consolidation loans through banks or credit unions. Only consider debt consolidation if you’re committed to changing spending habits. Debt consolidation will help you merge all your bills into a single debt. It will lower your interest rate and make it easy for you to pay off your debt. Sometimes, debt consolidation can increase your interest rate, or might be low only during an introductory promotion period. Make sure you sign up for a plan with the same low interest for the full period of the loan!
Never wait until a bill goes to collections. Negotiate early! Hospitals may be willing to offer you a discounted price if you offer to pay in full on the same day.
Ask about discounts for upfront payments, hardship programs, or income-driven payment plans.
Use medical cost comparison tools or billing advocates to reduce charges. A Medical Billing Advocate can help you negotiate the bill down. They will also help find overcharges and errors and appeal excessive charges.
Explore payment plans, Medicaid eligibility, or nonprofit hospital discounts. Ask for hardship assistance. Many hospitals are required by State law to provide discounted services for low-income patients.
Warning: Medical credit cards often offer 6–12 months of 0% interest, but can carry high rates afterward. Use only if you’re sure you can repay within that window. You can also get a medical loan from a reputed lender. Shop around and compare APR (interest rates and fees), fixed and variable rates, origination fees, loan repayment terms and speed of loan process.
If you’re stuck with high-interest student loans, start by calling your lender. Sometimes, just asking can lower your rate. Shop around for interest rates and special deals and use them as leverage to negotiate with your bank or credit union. Provide proof of financial hardship to explore modifications. If you've not had luck on your own, talk to a loan negotiating company that specializes in student loans. They might be able to help you negotiate lower rates with lenders.
Refinancing is a great option if you have private or mixed loans, it can simplify payments and reduce interest. Even setting up autopay may drop your rate by 0.25%.
Some lenders offer perks for good grades, graduating, or referrals.
Explore repayment assistance and forgiveness programs, especially if you work in public service or high-need fields. Nonprofits and state-funded programs may offer aid, grants, or even pay off loans in exchange for volunteer work.
h) For Home mortgage and car loan: 🟠
If interest rates have dropped since you took out your mortgage or car loan, refinancing can lower monthly payments, reduce total interest, or let you tap into equity. It’s also a smart way to switch from variable to fixed rates or pay off a loan faster.
Even a slight rate drop can save you thousands over time, so shop around and compare options—it can offer both short-term relief and long-term savings.
2. Renegotiate your current debt repayments. 🟠
If your current debt is overwhelming, don’t ignore it, renegotiate it.
First, talk to a financial advisor or a debt relief lawyer.
Contact creditors and explain your financial hardship. Many creditors prefer negotiation over default, so be proactive.
Request lower interest rates, deferred payments, or new payment plans.
Work with accredited credit counseling agencies to create a debt management plan.
If you have huge credit card debts, call the American Fair Credit Council. They can help you find ways to reduce your principal balance and interest rates on your debt and help you pay it off and restore your credit.
If you have decent credit, a personal loan from a credit union or bank is far better than payday loans.
Compare APRs, terms, and fees.
Choose fixed interest rates and no-prepayment-penalty options.
Avoid loans with vague terms, balloon payments, or variable rates unless you fully understand the risks.
Warning: You need to be careful when you get this loan. Not all credit unions offer official PALs. The ones that don't offer official PALs might have low interest rates, but high application fees and other fees that drive up the cost of the loan. You need to find one that is regulated by the National Credit Union Administration. There are also several private banks (and payday lenders!) who fool people into thinking they are getting a "payday alternative loan". Do you research, read the fine print, and don't get it if the interest rates and fees are outlandish. As a rule, don't borrow from any lending institution who won't check your credit score! There's no bigger red flag that that! (I want to add a note about borrowing from or withdrawing from your 401K. I wouldn't recommend this unless you are in an absolute dire strait. But sometimes, it might be your only option if you are unable to find a low-interest loan with a bank! Talk to a financial advisor about it).
4. Consider setting up a donation pay on a crowdfunding platform. 🔴
For urgent, unexpected expenses (like a medical crisis), crowdfunding can provide community-based support.
Share your story with honesty and humility.
Ask friends and community groups to help spread the word.
Boosting your income, even temporarily, can make a major difference.
Offer tutoring, babysitting, pet care, or food delivery.
Sell handmade crafts, baked goods, or used items online.
Ask the local stores in your area if they have any open positions.
Take up gig work like freelancing or virtual assistance.
Schools and colleges are always looking for substitute teachers.
Join a ride-hailing service, apply for a first-responder job, deliver packages.
Make money filling out surveys, writing product reviews, joining focus groups.
Many of these can be done with flexible hours and no upfront investment.
You can visit your local employment agencies and ask them if they have any temporary jobs that need your skill..
Local nonprofits and religious institutions often offer assistance for:
Food and groceries
Utility bills
School supplies and bills
Rent and medical needs
If a nonprofit does not offer a service that works for you, they will point you to one. So don't hesitate to ask them for help! Also look up your city's emergency relief programs. Dial 211 to connect with social services in your area. Many offer one-time emergency funds or ongoing support.
7. Rent a room in your house. 🟠
If your home has extra space:
Rent out a room short-term or long-term.
Consider renting to a trusted student, senior, or remote worker.
Ensure clear expectations and a formal agreement.
Renting a room is a fairly straightforward process, but each State and County has its own laws. Be sure to comply with all the requirements. Write up a short lease agreement so the renter understands their obligations. Renting a room will save you a few hundred dollars (or more, depending on where you live) a month! This is a powerful way to offset mortgage or rent costs.
8. Sell your personal items. 🟢
Instead of pawning valuable items (which offers very little cash and high interest), sell them directly through online marketplaces or garage sales.
Items like electronics, jewelry, clothing, tools, and musical instruments can bring in quick cash.
Consider selling your car and buying a cheaper used vehicle if your current one is under a loan.
Avoid pawnshops... they offer less than 50% of resale value and charge exorbitant rates (up to 300% APR in some states). You will also be charged other fees, such as insurance and storage costs!
9. Borrow from a loved one, and do it the right way, with the right attitude. 🟢
A short-term loan from a trusted friend or family member is often the safest and least expensive solution for small bills like groceries or utilities.
Be honest and specific about your situation and how you'll use the money.
Draft a written agreement (a promissory note) with clear repayment terms.
Maintain trust by repaying on time and staying accountable.
Even if they can’t help financially, emotional support or help with childcare, carpooling, or shared meals can save you money.
Important Note: Avoid asking loved ones to co-sign a loan unless absolutely necessary.
Co-signing a loan is a serious commitment. While it can help you secure a lower interest rate or get approved when your credit isn’t strong enough, it also puts your loved one at significant financial risk. If you fail to make payments, the co-signer becomes legally responsible for repaying the loan, sometimes the full amount. This can damage their credit score, affect their debt-to-income ratio, and even limit their ability to qualify for future credit or housing. In some cases, there may also be tax implications. So think of co-signing as asking someone to take out a loan themselves. It’s a huge ask, and not one to be made lightly. If you must go this route, be completely transparent. Treat it with the same seriousness and professionalism as you would when applying to a bank—because to them, it’s exactly that.
Many employers offer salary advances, especially if you’ve been a loyal and reliable employee.
This is a loan against your future wages, usually with structured repayment.
Some companies deduct the full amount from your next paycheck, others spread it out.
There may be fees or repayment clauses in case of termination. Ask for details.
If your employer doesn’t have a formal program, propose a plan and offer to take on extra work. You might be surprised how willing they are to help. Offer to work more hours or pick up extra shifts. If you are earnest, your employer will help you.
Conclusion:
High-interest payday and predatory loans may seem like quick solutions, but they often lead to deeper financial trouble. Instead, take control by: Using available resources (family, employers, nonprofits). Re-evaluating your bills and expenses. Increasing your income through smart, short-term strategies.
These steps won’t just help you meet immediate needs, they’ll help you regain long-term financial control. You’ve got more options than you think. And you don’t have to do this alone.
Read more about:
Why Payday Loan Is a Trap. This article talks about how Payday Loans trap people in a debt-cycle by exploiting legal loopholes, following exploitative practices, and deceiving people.
Ten tips to make your food budget stretch till the end of the month. This article shares shopping tips to get the most bang for your buck. It shares where and when to buy your food and what to avoid.
From Snowballs to Avalanches: Finding the Right Debt Repayment Strategy. Common strategies and help you find the right debt repayment method for your situation.
Resources:
MIT Living Wage Calculator: This tool estimates the minimum income required to meet basic living expenses in specific regions, promoting awareness of labor practices and sustainable economic systems.
Visit our Resources page for a full directory of government and nonprofit support programs and services.
Comments